Note: if you read the previous two posts of this blog, some of my comments below will make more sense. Also, this is a rant, pure and simple. A bunch of Professional Bloggers behaviour sickened me as a person, consumer, a reader of their blogs, and someone who blogs non-professionally. Not all of them behaved this way, but enough of them did to warrant this post. I encountered them after being invited by Dell to a roundtable meeting with other Dell customers, bloggers, and Michael Dell. And yes, I left some details intentionally vague. Also, not all of the Professional Bloggers I am talking about were the ones at Dells rountable. If you read this and don't think it applies to you, it likely doesn't. The last statement at the end of this post is very telling...
If you don't want to read the whole rant, here's the summation: I observed a number of well known Professional Bloggers behaving inconsiderately, for the purpose of sensationalism, to create news, be the news they create, then blog about eachother, in order to self-indulgently promote their medium, their industry, themselves, and their sites. Tabloid journalism has *nothing* on these guys, and I wouldn't blame corporate america from locking their doors to every other professional blogger after this. (Though I know they won't, sensationalism works.)
Does that mean what they do isn't valuable? No. Both consumers and corporations benefit from the sensationalistic hype, and information these bloggers relate to their readers. However, it's now evident to me, that many of these individuals have gone beyond having a voice, to being narccisistic PR tools. They overlook details that would benefit their readers and the public in general, but not the companies they've been granted exclusive access to. In the trade-off, I believe they've lost the qualities that made them great reporters, which maybe they never claimed to be or aspired towards being, but many people see them as none the less. Which leads directly to my point...
we shouldn't mistake bloggers for reporters. Journalistic integrity has been a joke for decades now, but the Professional Bloggers I observed this past week have taken integrity and human consideration and stomped on it in exchange for their capitalistic dreams. -> But hey, it's America and chasing your dream means stepping on everyone else, right? <-That's sarcasm
So, this week at CES, I felt as if I were a wide eyed, wanna-be actor, experiencing the reality of Hollywood's dark side for the first time. Except I am a blogger, if non-professionally,and the industry that has left me bewildered, offended, and disgusted, is that of the Professional Blogger.
I don't mean Corporate Bloggers who represent their company online. I also don't mean the enthusiastic guy or gal who still blogs to have a voice. I mean the self-indulgent, cliquish, and in my opinion... completely misguided Professional Bloggers. Sure there are exceptions, but I met fewer of those at CES this year than I did the self-interested scene whores. (Boy am I in for it now.)
So, why did I feel the need to spaz out over this and make myself a target? It's simple.. After meeting them, I hate myself now for having enjoyed their work for so long. Don't worry, I don't have the temperament to torture myself over it. So, I'll get over it after I have my say.
Now, to their credit, I didn't experience direct rudeness. But I did suddenly feel like I was back in HS, and standing next to some snobby clique of self-appointed elites. The reality though, as I saw it, was a group of snarky, flippant, self-indulgent, inconsiderate and irresponsible individuals milking a potential cash cow of a new industry. Some of them may still be decent people, some may still be decent bloggers, but the rest... are only interested in promoting their industry and their sites, to the exclusion of all else. Truth, facts, real news, and personal consideration fell by the wayside of promotionalism, sensationalism, and the behaviour of a horde of electronic tabloid gossip mongers.
And as I haven't named names, if you're taking offense by this point, then you know who you are. Don't assume I'm talking about you, but if the shoe fits.. I can think of some things you can do with it, other than wearing it, or kicking me with it.
A large part of my point here is that when I saw these people "work" and then saw the resulting blog posts they produced, it made me sick to my stomach. They were too busy *being* the news, to report a great deal of valuable information that consumers, readers and most other people could have benefited from. So, am I going to report this news I believe they overlooked? Yes. With a few exceptions where taking my thoughts directly to the source will get the issue addressed far more expediently and benefit everyone by it. Then I'll report it once the problem has been resolved.
So I challenge the Professional Bloggers who have been busy challenging and ridiculing companies that don't otherwise compensate them for positive feedback. The challenge is to go back to when your tone of voice spoke volumes about improving industries other than your own. When you were a consumer crusader over issues you honestly thought were wrong, and not just sensationalistic. Go back over your notes, video and audio recordings and see where you can most benefit your readers in ways other than infotainment.
And I say this because... Professional Bloggers are now being let into government offices, courtrooms and other venues where traditional media outlets were the sole eyes, ears and voices of the public. Your integrity as a person, and a professional matters. You have access to the movers and shakers of the business world and entertainment outlets. Don't sell the rest of us out to get there.
Oh, and when you don't want to be overheard talking about other people, don't whisper at the volume of a low shout around the corner of a crowded hallway. It could have waited until you got back to the bloghaus, really.
End Rant.
-Ryan/DL